Introspection is so much like everything else in that you hold onto certain things longer than you should and you use old lenses to view a new life. You know you know yourself and that causes as many problems as not knowing yourself at all, because you have this identify as a self-aware person and you don’t know who you’d be without it. You cling so tightly to the knowledge you have of yourself that it sometimes blinds you from seeing the person you’re becoming.
I’m feeling very differently and realizing months too late that I’ve been trying to stuff myself into old molds, trying to make sense of myself with dated categories, and not being honest in admitting that things aren’t lining up anymore. It seems not to make sense, because it’s not a regression. I’m not holding onto the past, because it’s better. I’m holding onto it because it’s what I know and for all my thinking and planning, life has surprised me.
I’ve been slow in waking up to this new reality. It started when I first began talking about the anxiety I was experiencing. I just kept thinking, this is not me. Depression I would have expected, but anxiety and feelings of near-mania were nowhere to be found in the person I knew as myself. Even now that I’m not experiencing either as a problem, I have to realize that the person capable of going to those places is different from who I was before.
One image of myself I have been holding onto for far too long is the girl who was in remedial reading, who did not measure up to her advanced placement friends. It’s been fifteen years since I suddenly and surprisingly made the turn toward caring about school and succeeding at it and yet I still carry those feelings of insecurity and inadequacy. Thinking about that history, I realize that this big change I’m feeling now is not unprecedented and my need to hold onto old identities is nothing new.
As much as I feel like a million different people all at once, I can identify movements of my life, their beginnings and ends marked by big mostly-internal changes. They make more sense looking back than they did when I was experiencing them. The first movement was ages 1-11 when I seemed to change quite suddenly from lost and messy and remedial to focused and driven and compulsively organized. The second was ages 12-20 when I changed from complacent and uninspired to engaged and deeply interested in so many things. I think this is the start of the fourth movement and I can’t precisely define the change, because I only know the people I’ve been.
When you change, even dramatically, you don’t shed your former identities. I talk about the people I’ve been only because I’m surprised at how different they are from who I am now, but your past is always with you and it powerfully shapes how you see the world and who you become in that world. The movement that follows is always a reaction to the one before. That’s in part what’s so confusing about it, because you go from one extreme to the other–scattered to focused, indifferent to engaged, passionate but very uncertain to whatever I’m becoming now.
I keep trying to put words to the way I feel now and how it’s different from before. Recognizing it as different was the first step. I still have those earlier insecurities and the love for school that developed out of that and the apathy that turned into before I later found so many things to care about that I couldn’t make sense of them all, but I have more clarity and more confidence and I feel more empowered and more excited about life. I haven’t figured out the downside and I don’t mean that to sound pessimistic. It’s just that the freedom I felt as a kid came with insecurity, the life I created for myself as a good student came with rigidity and a preoccupation with perfection, and the move from apathy to engagement came with overwhelming confusion. Every person I’ve been has held together contradictions. None was simple or easy to understand. It seems I could only make sense of it once I was onto the next. Maybe it will be two and maybe it will be ten years before I’ll be able to define this change, but I will spend every day trying to figure it out.

{ 11 comments… read them below or add one }
“When you change, even dramatically, you don’t shed your former identities. I talk about the people I’ve been only because I’m surprised at how different they are from who I am now, but your past is always with you and it powerfully shapes how you see the world and who you become in that world.”
This really spoke to me. I think I have changed dramatically in the last year or two, and it bothers me that people I knew 3 years ago continue to define me by who I was then and not who I am now. Your past definitely shapes how you see the world and who you become in the world – but sometimes it’s through realising and accepting the mistakes we’ve made as “former selves” that we allow ourselves to become stronger, different, better people.
I think that the trickiest thing about becoming a new person in these senses is the people around you. What Emily Jane says above is really true. It seems to me that in order to move into new phases of your life you have to find the people that fit that phase. It’s hard to do it just by yourself.
Also, I’ve been lurking with a Google Reader subscription for a while and I figured I should say “Hi.” I was inspired by your Vlogs to do one of my own!
I totally understand how you are feeling. When I was in elementary school, I was shy and awful at math. I still feel scared when it comes to performing any sort of math problem in front of people, and I do have shy moments that take me back to my 9 year old days. It is only when I stop and realize that I HAVE changed – then I stop and focus on reality. Oh, and we should definitely grab a drink this summer when I’m back in town. Not sure when that will be but I will let you know!
I’ve changed a lot since graduating from college, but like you I still expect myself to react to certain situations in the old way because that’s all I’ve known. At least you are acknowledging that you’re going through some sort of growth process. That’s huge.
I think we’re a lot alike, and I feel the same way: I can feel and sense shifts and changes taking place. It’s not about shedding who we were, but about growing more fully into ourselves.
Can’t wait to see where it takes you.
Also, I hope this doesn’t come across as insulting, but the fact that you were in remedial reading literally stuns me. As a teacher, it gives me hope and excitement to think that some kids who might struggle now with schoolwork might one day become Ph.D candidates. Makes my job seem worthwhile, you know?
Favorite line: the fact that we don’t shed our previous identities… even if we want to, even if we are no longer that person, this is just so right on.
I used to be a huge nerd (like I wore a daffy duck t-shirt to school on a regular basis when i was in middle school), totally self-conscious around boys (well, i still am, but not as badly as i used to be), and more of an introvert. parts of me from those days still exist. Probably won’t ever change, and I’m learning to be okay with that.
You seem very excited about what’s going on in your life right now. I can definitely sense a change in attitude in your writing since I first started reading your blog. You come across as being happier somehow, or at least more at ease with who you are, and that’s a really good thing.
I think this may be my fav post of yours ever. So insightful.
I’ve never really thought about this but I really feel that I’ve been living in the same mindset of who I was five, six, seven years ago. I still see myself as a shy, scared fifteen-year-old who doesn’t have a clue of how the real world works. But I think it’s time for me to grow up and realize I have grown up and see myself of how I really am.
Thanks for this.
I can completely relate to this Ashley. I’m becoming a different person, I can feel it but I can’t quite pinpoint it. Its hard to let go of the person you were to become the person you are meant to be.
Sometimes I wonder if we ever really figure life out?
I think I’ve got a grasp at it at certain points, only to be shaken up, confused and questioning everything again. There is a line from “Heart of the Matter” by Don Henley that expresses this well: “The more I know/ the less I understand/ and all the things I thought I knew/ I’m learning again.”
The point is, well, that I just don’t know. haha. I don’t know enough about life yet, only what I’ve experienced up to this point. Guess that’s why they say, “Youth is wasted on the young.” We’re not so wise, yet.
I think I’ve given an ultra-confusing comment. But oh well.